I love the idea of this product and I wanted to love this product. Tarte claims that this is a long lasting liner. The liner didn’t last even 30 minutes on my waterline and only lasted 1-2 hours on tightline. Since this liner is specifically marketed and an inner rim liner, this was disappointing. The liner tip also breaks off quite easily so beware of that. I do like the petiteness of the liner so I will probably continue to use it just not tightline or waterline with it.